Further discussions about Cardiff Airport

A big meeting organised by Western Gateway was held on Monday 20th May 2013, with the First Minister of Wales, Carwyn Jones, in attendance. We are still going over our notes on the meeting and will report on mentions and consequences for the railway spur or the Vale line soon. In the meantime, here are a couple of links to media reports on the meeting:

The BBC reports on proposals being put forward by Western Gateway to see Cardiff Airport as a long haul hub airport.

Wales Online also reports on claims for Cardiff Airport’s long haul potential and focusses on pressure to reduce Air Passenger Duty.

Cardiff airport isn’t the only air transport solution that has been discussed recently. The Institute of Welsh Affairs has released a report focussing on the potential for a Severnside airport to eventually replace both Cardiff and Bristol airport.

Cardiff Airport want your feedback

Cardiff Airport are asking for your opinions on how they could improve their service. Do take a moment to give them some feedback.

Don’t forget to mention particular air routes that you would like to see added – in an ideal world. The outcome depends not only on the airport but operators’ willingness to work with them. The airport people will at least read your comment, so you just never know!

(We’re sharing this because it’s of interest to supporters of the Stop The Spur campaign. Obviously if you have a message for the airport then please send it directly.)

 

 

The idea of an express bus service to Cardiff Airport

There has been plenty of coverage about the Welsh Government’s acquisition of Cardiff Airport. Earlier this week we saw how the number of passengers has just dipped below one million per year.

Further down that BBC story there’s an interesting quotation from Eluned Parrott who is the local Liberal Democrat Assembly Member:

[...] Welsh Liberal Democrat business spokeswoman Eluned Parrott had hoped Mrs Hart would bring forward plans for an express bus service from central Cardiff to the airport.

“This bus link is vital,” she said.

“A direct high quality bus service from Swansea to Bristol Airport via Cardiff will shortly be launched without any taxpayer assistance.

“The Welsh government really does need to start their service, which was first announced almost four years ago, as soon as possible.” [...]

This express bus seems like a very good idea to us at the Stop The Spur campaign. Whereas people often like to take a car or at least get a car lift to ease transport of luggage, an express bus could be a good value method of increasing local travel options. It comes without the serious problems associated with a rail spur (burden on the rail line, significant damage to the local environment and huge financial costs – to name three!).

Here’s another thing that would improve local transport options. We in the Vale of Glamorgan are all looking forward to the twice hourly rail service that will run on the Vale line, which is scheduled to begin in 2014. It will mean you can get to the Rhoose Cardiff International Airport station by train and then jump on the excellent shuttle bus between the station and the airport. People tend to forget about the shuttle bus – it’s a reason why a rail spur as suggested in the old Local Development Plan is just not needed.

We offer these comments advisedly though. A new express bus service running from Cardiff centre, while welcome, would not be enough to revive the airport. As the airport management and others have said repeatedly, there is a relative shortage of air routes and flights. Only when the airport manages to attract more operators and extend the choice available will we start to see a real change in fortunes.

Transport to and from the airport, while relevant to the discussion, is less of an issue. As we’ve highlighted before, when surveyed only 3% of customers stated that accessibility of the airport was a reason not to choose Cardiff Airport compared to 57% citing choice of destinations or choice of flights as the reasons for picking another airport. It makes complete sense when you think about it. Here’s the pie chart from that market research which we reproduced last year:

By the way there’s a fuller comment from Parrott about the express bus proposal, on her website. It’s a good time for her to be reminding the Welsh Government of this proposal – and it would be superb to see the express bus happen.

New chairman at Cardiff Airport calls for routes, which ones would you like?

This has been a historic week for the airport, now that the Welsh Government have bought it for £52m.

Today’s news is that the new chairman Lord Rowe-Beddoe, formerly of the well regarded Welsh Development Agency, has said that the airport need to ‘get cracking’ on attracting flights:

THE new chairman of Cardiff Airport today said they need to “get cracking” on attracting more airlines following its sale to the Welsh Government.

Lord Rowe-Beddoe, who was appointed chairman of the new airport board yesterday, said it was key to attract more airlines to Cardiff, potentially driving down flight prices.

He told BBC Radio Wales: “We will be looking at that and improving the customer experience with the facilities of the airport. And most of all getting airlines to use it again.” [...]

He also has the challenge of retaining the routes and flights that are currently operating.

If you’re on Facebook we’re started a quick poll on the Stop The Spur page to survey which destinations you’d most like to see served. Go and vote for one!

The future of Cardiff Airport depends on air routes

For those who would like to see Cardiff Airport thrive BBC News Wales has a disheartening item today :

[...] Swiss carrier Helvetic is pulling out of Cardiff Airport, two years after the Welsh government spent £500,000 marketing Wales in Switzerland.

Helvetic started flying to Zurich from Cardiff in 2011, but had already dropped winter services after low demand and will not fly this summer. [...]

BBC Radio Wales also covered the news of Helvetic’s withdrawal and there’s a audio clip from this morning.

The accompanying news that operator Vueling is to increase services to Malaga and Alicante is a small consolation. We also note the recent reports of a possible new route to Hawarden in north east Wales once work on the new terminal there is completed.

As we’ve maintained from the start and as Cardiff Airport themselves have stated, air routes are the MOST important factor in the success or failure of the Airport.

That is, tinkering with the railway in the Vale of Glamorgan through the adding of a spur is not the answer – and would be a source of other big problems as we’ve outlined in previous posts here. In particular, can the daily commuters who live in the Vale be reassured that the rail services – already squeezed – will not be threatened by the addition of a needless extra burden on the line? We’ll have to wait for the new draft LDP from the Council before knowing for sure.

Welsh Government to buy Cardiff Airport

Who saw this coming?

Cardiff Airport will be bought by the Welsh Government, it has been announced.

First Minister Carwyn Jones revealed on Twitter today that a deal had reached with owners TBI to bring the struggling airport into public ownership.

TBI is a company owned by Spanish conglomerate Abertis (90%) and AENA (10%), the Spanish airports operator.

The nationalisation of the airport comes after a torrid few years which have seen declining passenger numbers and the loss of a number of key routes.

Mr Jones has spoken frequently of his dissatisfaction at the airport’s performance, which he labelled “not good enough” in March.

And in October, Plaid Cymru leader Leanne Wood called for a public stake in the airport.

The Welsh Government will now enter an exclusive period of due diligence that it said would take into account “financial, legal and vale for money considerations”.
[...]

Full story on WalesOnline today

Cardiff Airport’s performance woes and Carwyn Jones’ airport task force

In May this year you may have seen news of an investigation being conducted by the First Minister Carwyn Jones, with the help of a task force of various groups that have a stake in the airport.

One of the groups who were asked to make a representation to the task force is the Vale of Glamorgan Council. As we’ve noted before, because of new leadership the original Local Development Plan, including the rail spur suggestion, has been discarded. Council leader Neil Moore has talked about going ‘back to the drawing board’ on more than one occasion.

According to BBC News today, Cardiff Airport has suffered a drop in passenger numbers in a comparison of the first half of 2012 with the same period in 2011. Another group on the task force is the Airport itself who have given some pretty clear clues in today’s article about what they would like to see. A spokesperson gave a key reason for the unfortunate drop in passenger numbers:

The airport said the majority of the fall was due to the decision of bmibaby to pull out of Cardiff.

Then an echo of what Steve Hodgetts, the commercial director of the Airport, said in March this year:

The spokesperson added that route development remained a priority for the airport, which was working closely with the Welsh government through the newly established Airport Taskforce and Enterprise Zone.

In fact the Airport has never lobbied or asked or expressed a desire for a direct rail spur to answer its woes. It’s clear from the bmibaby example that retention of airlines is very important. It’s also clear that route development – that is, more and better air routes around the world including new partnerships with additional airlines – is what will help to bring more passengers to the airport.

As far as we’re aware the task force investigation is still ongoing and we’re looking forward to the findings when they are eventually published. Given the early signs given by the Council and the Airport – two influential members of the task force – we’d be willing to bet that the idea of a direct rail spur in the Vale of Glamorgan won’t be among the recommendations. Let’s hope so at least.

Vale Council to go back to the drawing board on LDP

As this site has gone a bit quiet since the Stop the Spur petition was delivered to the Vale of Glamorgan Council, we thought it might be useful to post an update on what’s been happening with the proposal to build an unnecessary rail link from the Vale line to Cardiff airport.

So what’s been happening? Well, first there was a local council election in which the ruling Conservative group lost their grip on the council, and although the Labour party was unable to establish a ruling majority, they are leading the Council under Neil Moore.

An article in the Western Mail in May of this year offers a hint as to what is happening with the LDP (Local Development Plan) and what this might mean for the Spur proposal.

Councillor Moore is quoted in the article:

“As far as I’m concerned we have got to go back to the drawing board.”

The article quotes a range of issues that the Labour Group want to revisit, including proposals to build up to 10,000 houses in the Vale. This may mean that the Spur proposal comes back in a different form, and we may have to go through the whole consultation process again.

Indeed, a recent article in the Penarth Times seemed to confirm this, with Counsellor Lis Burnett saying:

“I have already sought advice as to how we can extend future consultation on the plan.

“I am also currently carrying out a review of the statutory LDP process and am considering the options available to us as a new administration.

“I am concerned at various elements of the plan as drafted and remain committed to ensuring that we do whatever is necessary to deliver a sustainable LDP for the Vale of Glamorgan,” she added.

“As a result, no decision has yet been taken as to the timescale for future consultation, although that consultation will be far more meaningful.”

So it looks like the LDP will come back, although we don’t know whether it’ll contain the Spur proposal this time. We’ll keep an eye on it, and make sure we let you know what’s going on.

Thank you to everyone who signed the Stop The Spur petition

Thank you so much to everyone who signed the Stop The Spur online petition! A total of 481 people signed the petition to express their opposition to the rail spur proposal in the Vale of Glamorgan’s local development plan.

We went with farmer Gethin Jenkins to the council offices in Barry this afternoon to deliver the petition:

And here’s our receipt from the clerk.

Today’s 5PM consultation deadline has now closed and our online petition is now no longer accepting signatures.

We now leave this issue with the Vale planning department. If and when there is further news of the proposal we will update you via this website in the coming weeks and months. We are not 100% at this stage if we will need to campaign further in other ways. Let’s hope the planners recognise the validity of our arguments and the number of people (mostly local to the Vale but not exclusively so) who have put their names to them.

Optional highly detailed bit:

You might have spotted that the receipt refers to four separate letters submitted by our campaign. These are four identical feedback forms each with the petition text and signatures. The only difference between them are the policy numbers. The Vale of Glamorgan Council specifically requests that one objection per policy number is submitted and the rail spur covers four different policy numbers - SP7(1), SP2(3), MG13 and MG20(5). So that’s the format we used for the feedback from the Stop The Spur campaign.

 

Enjoy the sun!

(Maybe you could make a visit to Porthkerry Park to remind yourself what a precious environment we share in the Vale of Glamorgan.)
:-)

Direct rail spur: not what Cardiff Airport really needs

There is considerable discussion of Cardiff Airport in the press and the Assembly at the moment, following the First Minister’s recent comments about its management. There certainly are productive things that Assembly Members could do to help the airport thrive, but building a better rail link than the current one from Rhoose station is NOT top of the list. Here’s why.